The hidden job market
Today I joined UBC Okanagan's Co-op Sprint Series for a 30-minute session called Unlocking the Hidden Job Market. Morgan Marshall from the co-op office hosted.
One of the themes I talked about is that every major career change I had, there was a personal connection that enabled me to go to the next level.
Here's the conversation, lightly edited.
How did you go from your earlier roles to co-founding Transistor?
I graduated high school in '98, went to college for two years from '98 to 2000, and started working for a nonprofit that I'd been volunteering with. I worked with them doing youth work from 2001 to 2008. During that time, I also got my degree in business management.
Every major career change I had, there was a personal connection that enabled me to go to the next level.
While I was working for this nonprofit, there was this guy, Gregg Oldring, who took notice of me. He ran a software company called Mailout, located in downtown Edmonton. He had told my boss, "If Justin ever wants to leave, let me know."
When I decided I wanted to leave the nonprofit, I can remember for about a week I was handing out resumes and trying to apply for places. Then Gregg heard that I was looking for work, called me, and said, "Stop applying. I want to hire you."
That was good news for me, because I was applying for jobs I was not very excited about. If you've ever applied for jobs, you know how disheartening it is to take your resume around and have nobody really care about you.
I was 28 years old. I applied for the Apple Store. I applied to be a salesperson selling doors and windows, door to door. I would not have liked either of those, but I had bills to pay.
So this offer was just so great. And Gregg took me under his wing. I started in customer support, kind of at the bottom, and just worked my way up. By the time I left in 2014, I was product manager at Mailout Interactive.
The next job I got was with a startup in Portland. The founder there was Joe Stump. Joe was a guy I originally met on Twitter. Then he started listening to this podcast I was doing called Product People, where I was interviewing startup founders and people building software products. Eventually, he said, "I'd like to hire you." So that became my next career jump.
I worked with him for a year and a half until they got acquired. By this point, I'd been doing some other things that had built a little bit of an audience: podcasting, blogging, and writing a newsletter. I wrote a book called Marketing for Developers that did well enough that I didn't need a job for the next couple of years.
During that time, one of my podcast guests, Chase Reeves, invited me to a conference in Portland called XOXO. While I was there, I met this guy named Jon Buda. Jon and I stayed in touch. Every year, we would get together. We started building projects together.
At the end of 2017, he was working for Cards Against Humanity, and they were about to launch a podcast. He said, "I'm thinking about building some software to help them publish the show and distribute it to Apple Podcasts and Spotify." And I said, "Jon, we've got to do this together as a company."
In January 2018, we signed our partnership agreements and started working on Transistor together. This business has just been more than I could have ever dreamed of.
So that's my career so far, and a little insight into how each time there was a person connected to that jump.
Can you talk about your past co-op student, and how a meaningful connection turned into something other than the traditional application process?
I think this is so key. I've been telling this story a lot.
Just as background, Transistor is a small company. We don't hire very often. Every time the idea of doing a co-op came up, it just seemed like too much administrative work for me. It wasn't even on my radar.
But I've been running this meetup in Vernon called Geek Beers. It happens the last Thursday of every month, and I've been running it since 2012 or something like that. We often have students come around, especially lately as comp sci and tech hiring has gotten more challenging for juniors.
What impressed me about Ian, the co-op student we ended up hiring, was that he showed up consistently. He was always very clear about what he was looking for, and clear in a way that was also vulnerable: "Hey everybody, I'm here because I'm looking for a co-op for this upcoming term. Here's the things I've been working on." He was clearly engaged, asked really good questions in conversation, and was good at answering questions as well.
But I'd say the important piece is that he kept showing up. Eventually I started to build a rapport with him. I knew who he was. I looked forward to seeing him. We had topics we talked about last time that we could talk about this time.
As he kept sharing his life, I got more invested in who he was as a person, but also just more impressed. Through him coming to this meetup multiple times, I was able to see: "Oh wow, this guy's a good communicator. Wow, this guy seems to be a really hard worker." I invited him to our meetup Slack group, and he started participating in discussions there.
All of this built up. And I think that's the important piece: this isn't something you just do once. It's a repeated thing. You just keep showing up, keep showing up, keep showing up, keep building a relationship, which is really what most of life is.
Eventually, Ian posted a YouTube video in our Slack group: "Hey everybody, just wanted to share. This is a video I made for my last co-op on everything I accomplished, the things I learned." I watched it. It was the culmination of everything I'd seen about Ian before, and I was like, "Man, he's just showing so much initiative." The fact that he was willing to do this and post a video about it, and that he did such a good job of clearly communicating what he had accomplished. I was like, "I think we should try to hire this guy."
That's what pushed me to reach out to the UBCO co-op program and say, "We want to get involved. We want to try to hire Ian for the summer."
The nice thing about hiring somebody you've known for a couple of years is that it takes so much of the risk out of it. A lot of people look at this from the applicant side. On the employer side, I can tell you, it is so risky to hire anybody new. It's scary, because you're investing a lot. You don't want to have to fire people.
Being able to see how Ian shows up, for him to share what he was working on, his projects, some of his struggles, I just felt like I had a better view of him as a person. It made that hiring decision that much easier.
Then he showed up for the co-op during the summer, and he just killed it. He understood intuitively that he wanted to, A, solve the boss's problem: solve my problem. He was always reaching out, asking how he could do that. B, he was very outcome-driven. And C, he was willing to start in customer support.
He's a comp sci student, but we had him doing customer support. At our company, I'll probably never hire someone again who doesn't start in customer service. It helps you learn the company so quickly. Instantly, as a boss, I can see how you interact with customers, how you take care of them, if you're willing to go the extra mile, if you're a good communicator. It's just a perfect proving ground for new hires.
He demonstrated just how capable he was, and how much he cared. We told him that when he finishes his degree, he should definitely apply for a full-time position.
On an old podcast, Adam Wathan talked about getting 1,600 applications for two developer roles, then hiring two people he already had a relationship with. From an employer standpoint, why is a warm relationship always safer than the online portal stack?
This has even gotten worse now with AI. On the applicant side, you've got applicants firing out thousands of applications a day. On the employer side, they're using AI to automatically deal with this deluge of applications, and they're ranking them in all sorts of ways.
A big company is going to play that game. If you're applying at Microsoft, that's part of the game. But even at Microsoft, having a warm introduction, a warm connection, helps you jump to the top of the list.
Actually, even in this coworking office, I was just talking to another guy here. There's a company called Kit.com. They do email newsletters. I know the founder. I noticed they have six positions open. I told this fellow he should apply, and I said, "When you apply, let me know, and I will let the people there know that I can vouch for you."
It's such a risk to hire a person. If you get stuck with a bad employee, it drags the whole team down. It becomes a headache for you as a boss and for the team. The goal when you hire somebody is that you want the employee to solve your problems. You don't want them to give you more problems.
So warm introductions and existing relationships are going to beat a cold application every time. In fact, if I was applying for roles, I would put 80% of my energy into getting the warm introduction, and only 20% of my energy into just applying cold.
It's funny. People think that 80% of actually developing a relationship seems so unclear and difficult. But the truth is, you'll probably get to your outcome faster, which is getting hired.
I know people who've been blindly sending out applications for years, every single day, and it's debilitating for them. So which is harder? Spending years sending out applications, hoping you're going to win the application lottery? Or doing the harder work up front: going out, building some relationships, seeking out some people, trying to get some coffee meetings?
Maybe you get turned down five times out of ten. Those are still great odds. And if you do get a coffee meeting with somebody, you can say, "Hey, just to let you know, I'm graduating at this time. I'm trying to figure out how I should be applying. Do you have any advice for me?" These things all stack on top of each other.
There's an old saying: hard conversations now, easy life. Easy conversations now, hard life in the long term. I would do the hard things now so that you have a better life in the future, as opposed to constantly doing the easy thing. Everybody's doing the easy thing. The way to stand out is to do the hard thing.
For students who don't feel like they have enough experience or work to put out there, what are some practical ways to start building in public?
I realize this is a struggle, as I've talked to UBC students. The course load can be quite a lot, so sometimes it's hard to think about doing anything extra. But if you do have time, or after you've graduated, or if you have a moment over the holidays, here's one way to stand out.
If I was a student in comp sci or engineering right now, I would be really focusing on security. With AI, there's been an influx of vulnerabilities. If you have some natural interest in that, just geek out about it, and then tell people about it.
It's not enough for you to just geek out about it in your own time. You have to tell people about it. That could be:
- Every time I realize something interesting, I'm going to post about it on LinkedIn.
- Every time I realize something, I'm going to walk to work, turn on voice memos, record it, and publish it as an audio podcast.
- I'm going to record a quick YouTube video with my reaction to the latest security vulnerability.
Those things can all be very, very helpful. I realize there's a spectrum of people who like to work in public and not work in public. But having some of it is helpful, because it's evidence that you are interested, passionate, and thinking about a topic. The more evidence you can have out in public, the better for you.
In general, I look at people's portfolios and sites, and I'm not seeing enough. I'm seeing too much generic stuff. In tech, it's always, "Here's some open source projects I worked on at school," or "Here's a website." But I want to know what you really geek out about. I want to know what you get really excited about. I want to hear that you've done some thinking. I want to see the projects you're building. I want to see the community work you're doing.
For example, one thing I don't think Ian had on his resume, but I would have loved to have seen: he worked at a summer camp for a bunch of summers. There was so much in that position, him lifeguarding at a summer camp: here's what I learned about leadership, here's what I learned about running a team. There were all these lessons he could have talked about.
Depending on who you're applying to, especially if it's a smaller company, I'd be okay with breaking out of the confines of the generic resume. Really show me what you're excited about. Really show me what you genuinely learned. Really show me your experience, not just at school and at work, but other volunteering you've done, other events you've gone to. I want to see all of that. The more evidence there is, the better.
And if you wrote a good paper... everybody has that one professor or class they really like, and you work really hard on those papers. I would be publishing those publicly. Make them a blog post. My favourite class in university ended up being business ethics, and a lot of those papers ended up becoming blog posts that I shared publicly. It just shows that you're fired up about something. That's what you want to see.
Another good example is Kyla Scanlon. She really started getting excited about economics, started posting about economics, and has built a whole career around that. Employers love to see that stuff.
In coffee chats, what behaviours leave a positive impression and make you more likely to help a student expand their network? And what's the best way to ask for a recommendation?
Some basics in a coffee meeting: you eventually need to build the skills of being social. There are some bare minimum things, like your appearance. Be well-groomed, be clean, wear reasonable clothes. Then you have to develop some habits around social interaction: learning to look at somebody when you're speaking to them, learning how to acknowledge them, learning how to get over your nerves, which we all have to do.
That can take time. While you're building those skills, I think it's okay to be honest. If you show up at a coffee meeting and you're nervous, it's okay to say, "I just want to let you know I've been really nervous about this all day." That can be disarming in and of itself, because you're speaking it out loud. And the other person can say, "Oh, don't worry about it. I'm not going to bite. We're just hanging out."
Sometimes you do need to practice beforehand, until it becomes natural. You might want to practice in a mirror: "What kind of things might this person ask?" They're probably going to ask what I'm doing in school. They're probably going to ask what I want to do after. They're probably going to ask what my dream job would be.
If I ask you those questions and you don't have an answer, it can come off as, "Oh, this person's not really a go-getter, or ambitious, or that serious." But if you get really excited about something, and I can see the passion in your voice, and I can see you're really interested in it, that is really helpful.
Every community and every industry category has what are called super connectors. They're people who know a lot of people. You probably want to connect with super connectors more than people who aren't. For example, if you came to me and said, "Man, I'm really into manufacturing or physical product design," I could recommend you to a startup in Vernon that makes VO2 masks for athletes and does all their 3D printing here. So connect with super connectors. Learn to identify those people.
And be okay to ask. At the end, just say, "Hey, is there anyone you can think of that I should connect with, or that you can refer me to?" It's okay to ask. And it's okay for them to say no.
For practicing this, one thing I've recommended to my own kids is that you can practice with strangers. Bringing up a conversation in a coffee shop with a stranger is one way to practice: "What are you reading?" or "What are you working on?" or "Hey, I see you around here a lot. My name's Justin." If you're sitting at the bar in a pub, it's a universal invitation to speak to the person next to you: "Hey, you watching the game? What's your favourite team?"
The thing I've said to my kids is that the truth is, most people want connection. Even if the stats are that you'll only get 8 out of 10, those are incredible stats for building up a muscle of learning how to interact with people socially.
So I would be practicing these things all the time: when you're at a coffee shop, when you're out in public. As you practice, you'll become way more confident when you're in person with somebody. You'll be able to tell yourself, "Oh, I've got evidence that I can do this. I spoke to that person at the coffee shop." Put it into practice right now, in your daily life.
Social skills, by the way, are something everybody can learn. Going to meetups is another low-stakes way to get into it. If you're looking for a low-stakes meetup, feel free to come out to Geek Beers in Vernon. It's just in a pub, and we try to be as welcoming as we can, especially to younger people.
Rapid fire questions:
Cold LinkedIn DM or cold email outreach?
You can do them, but there needs to be a warm background.
Here's a quick example. I just had someone from Vancouver reply to my email newsletter. He said, "Hey, I've been reading your blog and your newsletter for a while, listening to your podcast. I'm driving up from Vancouver. Will you have coffee with me?"
Instant yes. Because it's not somebody fake.
I get so many cold emails now, especially using AI, that pull out fake stuff like, "Oh, I was listening to your podcast," or "I was reading your blog." You can tell they're fake. But this was a real person who had been reading the newsletter. It was just an easy yes for me.
An example of a LinkedIn cold DM is another person I hired here, Michael Green. He had gone to another one of our local tech events, and I'd seen him a few times. He reached out on LinkedIn, and that got him a meeting. Eventually, that relationship ended up in a hire.
Finish this sentence: "If a student includes ___ in a cold DM, I'm hitting reply every time."
If it's clear they've been following the newsletter or the blog or the podcast. Or if they have a real question, one I can tell they're not just spraying out to everybody. If it's a real, genuine question about something I've written or something they heard me talk about on a podcast, that's a guaranteed reply.
I think it's even better showing up at local events: "Hey, I met you briefly at this event. I was the student that was struggling with this. Wondering if you have time for coffee?" Those are just such easy yeses to give.
Students have this free golden ticket, which is: if you are genuine and you approach a business leader... almost everybody I know who's a CEO or a founder loves to have questions from students, or students that want to go for coffee. As long as it's clear that you're genuine and you have a specific question you want to ask, I think you can DM any CEO or founder.
True or false: following up twice on a cold email or DM is pushy.
These days, the problem is that so much of it is being automated. If your first email sounds spammy or AI-generated or insincere or just kind of banal, then it doesn't matter how many times you follow up.
It's not that hard to write a genuine email that shows you actually know something about me or my company, or shows genuine interest in what we're doing. What would be an example?
"Hey Justin, I'm a UBC student here in Kelowna, and I've started this podcast about what to do when you're overloaded with stress during exam season. Would love to connect sometime."
That alone is like, "Oh wow, okay. They're local. They're in podcasting. I can go listen to it." Those kinds of things help.
You just can't be any sort of low-hanging fruit, like, "Oh, I'll just blurt this out. It'll be easy." No. Put some effort into it. Be strategic with how you're reaching out, and think about it like a relationship.
That's the biggest thing: bosses and people hiring, we're human too. We actually want to connect with other human beings. Just like anyone, I want to connect with interesting, ambitious people.
What's the best tip for someone walking into a local tech meetup completely solo?
If you're a student, just own the fact that you're a student. I don't think anybody would expect a student to be overly confident or overly put together. It's okay to be a little nervous.
I would try to get a sense of what people are wearing, so be reasonably presentable. And I would have some answers. People are going to ask:
- What are you studying?
- What do you like most about your program?
- What kind of struggles are you having right now?
- What kind of job would you like?
- What's your dream company to work for? Why?
Having answers to some of those questions makes you more relatable and more interesting. Don't be afraid to show some ambition: "I would really like to work for this company in this position someday." People like to see that too.
And get good at asking questions. This is another thing Ian is quite good at. You get kind of a golden ticket. There are no dumb questions. You can even ask questions that an older adult might not be able to ask: "What's it like being the CEO? How do you think about hiring? What are some things you look for in employees?" In an open forum, especially a meetup, you can ask all sorts of questions you might not normally be able to ask on LinkedIn or email.
I would put LinkedIn and email down the list, at four and five. There's other things you can do before that. Almost all in-person events would be a better use of your time.
Any final thoughts on the hidden job market?
The hidden job market is most of the job market. Almost all of the good jobs, almost all of the good opportunities, are in the hidden job market.
My encouragement to you is that even though it's going to be harder in the short term, it's going to be easier in the long term to just invest in this hidden job market. Really, it's about building relationships, networking, showing up at events, meeting people, building up your social skills, and getting interested in what other people are doing. Subscribe to some email newsletters, follow some interesting people on LinkedIn, follow some interesting podcasts.
One of the easiest warm intros you can do is just: "Hey, I've been reading your blog," or "I've been reading your posts on LinkedIn, and I've been really resonating with a lot of the things you're saying." That's an easy in.
I'm convinced that if you work hard enough in this hidden job market sense, you'll be able to find a job even in a hard job market.
The other hidden job market is that there are lots of employers that would hire, but don't have a job posting. A boss always has a list of things in the background: "Oh man, it'd be great if I had someone to do this." But we don't get around to doing a job posting. What ends up filling those roles is when we meet somebody who would fit in that slot, and we go, "Oh my gosh, you'd be perfect."
So just because there's not a job posting doesn't mean a company isn't hiring. It's worth it to go and speak with those folks.
Another easy one that I did when I was in college: I just reached out to a bunch of companies I wanted to work for and said:
"Listen, I've been following your company. I think you guys are amazing. I would love to work for a company like yours one day. I'm wondering if I can come for a tour, or come and meet you. I would just like to hear more about how you guys hire and what kinds of things I should be doing."
Anybody can do that. And now all of a sudden, they've got this ambitious self-starter at their doorstep, and they're touring you around. There are lots of creative opportunities like that.
And it's fun. It would be fun to go for a tour at your dream company, right? 80% of those companies didn't hire me or offer me a job, but it was still a great experience to go and see what they were doing and how they hire.
Cheers,
Justin Jackson
Connect with me on:
๐ฆ Bluesky
๐ผ LinkedIn
๐ Mastodon
๐งต Threads